Nipplerockian Demands Retraction After Rival Magazine Calls It “Not Even Real News” In Otherwise Glowing Review

The Newsroom—The Nipplerockian has formally demanded a retraction from The Advocate, the Salernan monthly magazine. Its November issue called this newspaper “remarkable,” “a chef’s kiss” and “Civ’s Onion,” then added that “it’s not even real news!”
“We have been called many things,” said a senior editor. “Skandic called us trespassers. Icenia called us ‘recent reporting.’ But nobody has ever questioned our accuracy in print. Especially not a magazine whose first issue came out after its second one.”
According to CivWiki, The Advocate’s Issue I is dated October 2026, while Issues II and III came out in August and September. Media historians say this makes The Advocate the first publication on the server to release its debut as a sequel. Issue I was titled “Auferstanden aus Ruinen,” or “risen from ruins,” after which the magazine folded for nine months. “It said it would rise from ruins,” said one historian. “It didn’t say in which order.”
Elsewhere in the issue, The Advocate calls this newspaper “satirical” and praises its “satire.” Editors have asked The Advocate to point out where the satire is, so it can be removed.
The review goes on to state that “you can be either high quality or funny.” The Nipplerockian was surprised to learn that The Advocate keeps track of which one it is. Its editorial board grades every issue on a scale from “A+ (exceptional)” to “F- (garbage).” Issue IV, released last month, is still listed on the wiki as “Anticipated,” with a grade of “TBD,” which analysts call the most honest review of a magazine they have ever seen. The Nipplerockian has now adopted the same scale. It awarded The Advocate’s review an A+ for content and an F- for the part where it says we are not real news.
The review also described most of the server’s other papers as “unremarkable” and “a sea of sameness.” The Nipplerockian stands in solidarity with them. That includes The Copper Polit, which The Advocate describes as “announced but nothing released,” a position The Advocate itself held for nine months.
Staff noted that the two publications have more in common than either would like. “We have written about Shadno twice this month,” said the editor. “He wasn’t the subject of either story. He just keeps turning up at the end.” This month, Shadno is also credited as a guest writer on The Advocate’s front page. “He has never written for us,” the editor added. “We have never asked. We’re starting to think that’s why he keeps turning up.”
The Advocate’s acknowledgements page lists Titan Industries as its sponsor. Titan Industries collapsed years ago. The page also invites readers to fill in a feedback form “so we can pretend to read them.” The Nipplerockian has filled in the form and asked for a retraction. It does not expect a reply.
The Nipplerockian is now calling on The Advocate to publish a correction stating that this paper is real news, high quality and “only accidentally funny.”
At press time, The Advocate had been sent a formal complaint, and The Nipplerockian’s editorial board had re-graded its own retraction demand from A+ to TBD.


